• Classic Jersey Italian Gravy - 24 oz.
$11.99
Subscribe Options
Delivery Frequency

Know what? Our classic Jersey Italian Gravy is made with 100% fresh vine-ripened tomatoes which gives it that natural sweetness you'll never forget. We never, never ever, make the gravy from concentrate, puree, paste or any cheap stuff like that. We make it the real old fashioned way. 100% all natural. No added spices and only 5 ingredients.

Ingredients: Vine-Ripened Tomatoes, Oil Blend (Canola Oil, Extra Virgin Olive Oil), Onions, Cane Sugar, Salt.

Organic

Natural and pure, using only 5 ingredients, yet packed with flavor. We don’t add any preservatives, artificial flavors or spices.

Authentic

Slow cooked over 6 hours, we take no shortcuts in making sure you get the real deal.

Award-Winning

Simply delicious. Our 5 star reviews will tell you all you need to know. Try it and see for yourself.

Customer Reviews

Based on 273 reviews
94%
(257)
2%
(6)
1%
(3)
1%
(2)
2%
(5)
A
Angela Azevedo
HATE TO ADMIT, BUT BETTER THAN MOM'S

My mother made the most delicious pasta sauce [gravy]. But now that she's gone, and took her secret recipe with her, I found a perfect substitute with Classic Jersey Italian Gravy!

C
Charlene Daniels
Nothing Compares

Hands down the best sauce available anywhere. We buy cases at a time and never let our supply dwindle.

D
Donna Launders

Classic Jersey Italian Gravy - 24 oz.

K
Kay
They messed with perfection. Edit: It’s Back!! Thank you!!

I’ve been enjoying Jersey Italian Gravy for quite some time now. I had found a jar in a random store, and absolutely loved it. I ended up going back to that store to buy the rest of what they had. I was addicted! When I ran out, I panicked. I was able to go online and find that they were sold at Whole Foods. From there on out I’d stock up, buying 8-10 jars at a time. Then I started buying cases on the Jersey Italian Gravy website. To date I’ve bought 4 cases, which that alone adds up to 48 jars, and that’s not to mention all the other jars I’ve bought before I started purchasing from the website…. I received this last case and as soon as I opened it and took a jar out, I could tell it was different. The gravy is darker, it smelled different, and definitely tasted different. I was confused, and truly thought that maybe my jars were labeled incorrectly. That would’ve been great because that would have meant that they didn’t dare change their perfect gravy! To be sure I ran to Whole Foods where I purchased another jar. I knew just by looking at it it was the same as I had at home. I bought it anyway just to be sure, and was really bummed to see that the gravy I enjoyed for so long, the only jarred gravy that I’ll eat, is completely different. The original gravy was a vibrant red and had a beautiful fresh crushed tomato consistency, the new jars are anything but that. It’s more of darker red, smoother consistency like so many other jarred gravies on the market. I’m devastated. I had tried just about every gravy on the market, and I had hated them all until I found Jersey Italian Gravy. I’m not sure why they messed with perfection. If it’s a cost thing, I would’ve paid a little more for the quality gravy I’ve bought so many times before, and for what I believed was the best jarred gravy on the market. Please consider going back to that delicious, vibrant red, fresh crushed tomato gravy that you’ve perfected for all these years. For comparison I took a picture of the “new” gravy vs. the original. 1st picture is “new” and 2nd picture is the original (taken from an Amazon review)

Edit: After writing this review, I received a response from Jersey Italian Gravy. They notified me that they did indeed change the gravy using “locally grown, fresh tomatoes” vs. “canned tomatoes.” They said they are “diligently working on perfecting it to bring it back to its original delicious flavor.” They said my “patience and understanding” are “appreciated.” I’m grateful for the response, and therefore needed to edit my review. I took them at their word and ordered another case. It was just delivered the other day, and true to their word, the gravy in this case was indeed a lot closer to the gravy I love. The color and the aroma were on point. I’m thrilled! Thank you for working so hard to bring back the best gravy on the market. This company clearly cares about the quality of their gravy, while also caring for their customers. I will happily continue to order from Jersey Italian Gravy, as well as continue to recommend them to family and friends. I’ve also given away a few jars to people, which is hard for me to part with, but I feel this gravy needs to be shared with others to enjoy too. Thank you, once again, for your time. Have a fantastic day!

Hi Kay,

Thank you for reaching out and sharing your concerns. We truly value the feedback we receive from our loyal customers, especially those who appreciate our gravy as much as you do.

We're constantly striving to enhance our products, and I'm pleased to hear that you've noticed our recent improvement in using locally grown fresh tomatoes instead of canned tomatoes. While this adjustment may have resulted in a slight difference in taste, please rest assured that we are diligently working on perfecting it to bring it back to its original delicious flavor.

Your patience and understanding as we undergo this refinement process are greatly appreciated. We are committed to delivering the high-quality products that our customers expect and deserve.

Thank you for your continued support, and we look forward to you growing with us as we strive for excellence.

Best Regards,
Jersey Italian Gravy

R
Rory Bennette
Taste

Not as good as the meatball shop gravy